Cake Shop · Milford on Sea, Lymington
Polly's Pantry Tearoom Menu & Prices
Planning what to order at Polly's Pantry Tearoom? This menu gathers the bakes you are most likely to find at a cake shop like this, with indicative prices for 2026.
Indicative menu. Items and prices are typical for this style of bakery and are not supplied by Polly's Pantry Tearoom. Always ask staff about allergens.
Cake by the Slice
- Biscoff cake sliceV £4.55 Caramelised biscuit sponge, Biscoff buttercream and a crunchy biscuit crumb.
- Salted caramel sliceV £4.75 Caramel sponge layered with salted caramel sauce and silky buttercream.
- Red velvet sliceV £4.85 Crimson cocoa sponge with cream cheese frosting and crumb decoration.
- Black Forest gâteau sliceV £4.95 Chocolate sponge, kirsch-soaked cherries and whipped cream with chocolate curls.
- Chocolate fudge cake slicePopularV £4.85 Three tiers of moist chocolate sponge with thick chocolate fudge frosting.
- Victoria sponge slicePopularV £4.85 Light vanilla sponge sandwiched with strawberry jam and vanilla buttercream.
- Carrot cake sliceVN £5.35 Spiced carrot and walnut sponge layered with tangy cream cheese frosting.
- Coffee and walnut sliceVN £5.35 Coffee sponge with espresso buttercream and candied walnut halves.
Whole Celebration Cakes
- Red velvet cake 8" (serves 14–16)V £50.00 Layered red velvet sponge with cream cheese frosting and piped rosettes.
- Photo cake 10" (serves 25–30)V £67.50 Large single-tier cake printed with your edible photo image.
- Lemon and raspberry cake 8" (serves 14–16)V £46.50 Lemon sponge with raspberry jam and lemon buttercream, topped with fresh berries.
- Chocolate fudge cake 8" (serves 14–16)PopularV £49.00 Rich triple-layer chocolate cake with ganache drip and chocolate shards.
- Drip cake 8" with personalised messageV £48.50 Buttercream cake with a chocolate drip, sweets and your message on a plaque.
- Victoria sponge 6" (serves 8–10)PopularV £22.00 Classic jam and buttercream sponge, finished with a dusting of caster sugar.
- Two-tier celebration cake 6"/8" (serves 30)V £166.00 Stacked sponge tiers in your choice of flavour with smooth buttercream finish.
Custom & Occasion Cakes
- Corporate logo cake 10"V £91.50 Large tray-style sponge with your logo printed or piped for office events.
- Bespoke birthday cake (from)PopularV £117.00 Designed to your theme with sugar-paste figures, toppers and hand piping.
- Wedding cake consultation and tastingPopularV £21.00 Sample flavours and plan your tiers, finish and flowers with our decorator.
- Christening cake 8"V £78.50 Soft pastel sponge cake with fondant decoration and personalised name.
- Gender reveal cake 8"V £52.50 Neutral outside with a pink or blue surprise sponge and sprinkles inside.
- Three-tier wedding cake 6"/8"/10" (serves 80)V £519.50 Elegant stacked tiers with semi-naked or smooth buttercream finish and fresh flowers.
Cupcakes & Mini Treats
- Vanilla cupcakePopularV £2.70 Light vanilla sponge topped with a tall swirl of vanilla buttercream.
- Box of 12 mini cupcakesV £19.00 Bite-sized cupcakes in assorted flavours with colourful toppings.
- Chocolate cupcakePopularV £2.65 Moist cocoa sponge with chocolate buttercream and sprinkles.
- Cupcake bouquet (12)V £48.50 Twelve cupcakes piped as flowers and arranged in a gift bouquet.
- Cake pops (box of 6)V £18.00 Cake crumb and frosting dipped in candy melts on a stick, decorated to theme.
Cheesecakes, Brownies & Bakes
- Whole cheesecake 8" (serves 12)V £35.50 Choose from vanilla, Biscoff, raspberry ripple or salted caramel.
- Rocky road slabV £3.00 Chunky chocolate traybake with marshmallows, biscuits and a dusting of icing sugar.
- Brownie box (6)V £18.50 Six thick brownies in mixed flavours such as Kinder, Biscoff and Oreo.
- New York baked cheesecake slicePopularV £5.05 Dense, creamy baked vanilla cheesecake on a buttery digestive base.
- BlondieV £3.35 White chocolate blondie with a chewy caramelised edge and soft middle.
- Triple chocolate brownieV £3.80 Gooey brownie packed with milk, white and dark chocolate chunks.
- Lotus Biscoff cheesecake slicePopularV £5.70 No-bake cheesecake swirled with Biscoff spread on a crushed biscuit base.
Coffee
- AmericanoVVGGF £3.10 Espresso lengthened with hot water for a smooth, rounded cup.
- Oat milk or syrup extraVVGGF £0.70 Add oat, soya or almond milk, or a vanilla, caramel or hazelnut syrup.
- EspressoPopularVVGGF £2.90 Single or double shot of our house blend espresso.
- LatteVGF £3.45 Espresso topped with plenty of steamed milk and a thin foam layer.
- Iced coffeeVGF £3.85 Espresso over ice with milk, sweetened with syrup if you like.
Ordering tips for Polly's Pantry Tearoom
- Arrive early for the widest choice – bread and the most popular bakes often sell out by lunchtime.
- Whole and celebration cakes usually need ordering in advance – allow a few days for standard designs and longer for custom work.
- Allergen information must be available on request under UK law – ask before you buy if you have an allergy.
Make a morning of it
All in LymingtonOther bakeries near Polly's Pantry Tearoom
Patisserie
Bridges
25 Saint Thomas Street, Lymington SO41 9NE
Closed · opens 9am todayHygiene 5/52.8 mi
Bakery
Shelleys Bakery
2 Southampton Road, Lymington SO41 9GG
Closed · opens 7:30am todayHygiene 5/52.9 mi